Takil vs NaniTal...from Tony Avent of Plant Delights Nursery
Posted: Wed Mar 31, 2010 12:54 pm
His newsletters are so interesting...he was talking about taxonomic name changes.
One section is about Takil vs ? Trachies...much discussed on PN.
Here's Tony's take:
One section is about Takil vs ? Trachies...much discussed on PN.
Here's Tony's take:
BarbThis brings me to the latest taxonomic snafu.trachycarpus palms. For years, we have grown three primary species: Trachycarpus fortunei, Trachycarpus takil, and Trachycarpus wagnerianus. There have been extensive articles written about Trachycarpus takil and the trek to find the real plant to gather seed (Princeps 37(1) 1993, pp 19-25). Guess what we learned in 2009?
They gathered seed off the wrong plants. It turns out that virtually everything in cultivation and in writings about Trachycarpus takil is actually a form of Trachycarpus fortunei from the Indian town of Nanital, so this plant is now referred to as Trachycarpus fortunei 'Nanital'. Although this represents a name change, it is quite different from the example above because this is simply a correction of an earlier error.
While we're discussing trachycarpus, another problem plant is Trachycarpus wagnerianus. This species was described from a single plant that was being cultivated in Japan and has never been seen or documented in the wild. This is a classic example of poor taxonomy, but was accepted for decades in the past when the opportunity for field studies was more difficult. It is our own and other palm growers contention that this is nothing more than a compact form of Trachycarpus fortunei and therefore, we are changing its name to Trachycarpus fortunei 'Wagnerianus'. This is not something new, having been proposed since 1977 (Principes Vol 21, 1977, pp. 155-160). I hope these examples illustrate the methods behind the name changing madness, and that all name changes aren't created equal.
If you could see them in person you would know they have so filifera blood.
